The amount of ignorance in the Garbage album description is incredible. Unfortunately, we are forced to read Stephen Thomas Erlewine's completely biased review that claims Shirley Manson's vocals are "thin, airy" and the band failed to pass his test of authentic rock. I'm sure he has just as much to say about Pearl Jam's credentials, right? Right?? I doubt it. Shirley was criticized 30 years ago for not being enough, and the rest of the band were written off because they were producers or engineers. Fine, it's not your style, but why is this the official album description?