cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Reporting AI Slop

wade-phase
Underground

Hello,

I've been a Pandora user for quite some time and recently a station of mine played a track by this "artist:"

https://www.pandora.com/artist/aria-sai/ARJP2fcxP6X6n9Z

I investigated the "artist" via external channels and found that it is not an actual person, but an AI generated fictitious entity posing as a person.

I do not know what Pandora's official policy is regarding AI slop, so let me briefly point out why this content is detrimental to your service.

While some people object to the content on the grounds that it is computer generated, I do not have a problem with this fact. I have listened to electronic music for a very long time and find the use of computers in music generation to be a very positive innovation that benefits both artists and listeners.

My problem with this content is that it is deceptive and created in bad faith. If the music were simply created by an artist using an AI voice synthesizer for the vocals, that would be totally acceptable. But instead of doing this, the creators of this music have chosen to obscure their identity and instead falsely claim that music they used a computer to generate was created by a non-existent computer-generated entity in an attempt to mislead listeners into emotionally attaching to this entity by exploiting their psychological sentiments which have been created through prior experiences with actual human artists.

It is clearly a bad-faith exploit, the sole purpose of which is to artificially elevate the popularity of this inexpensively computer-generated content to increase play counts and revenue intake from the licensing fees that Pandora pays to real artists for their content.

Tolerance of this behavior is detrimental to the service because Pandora exists to connect listeners with artists and musical content, and if Pandora is playing fake, low-quality, computer-generated slop instead of something an artist spent time and energy to create, then both the artists who create content and the listeners who consume their content are harmed because, instead of connecting the listener with an actual artist, Pandora has connected the listener with a scam artist whose intent in the creation of music is not expressive but exploitative.

When I visited the artist page to report this content as deceptive, I found no simple mechanism to flag it, so I decided to post here to request that you take down the content.

Also, given the increasing prevalence of AI slop content, I think it would benefit the service greatly to provide users with an easier mechanism for reporting the presence of deceptive content like this, as posting to a community forum is an inefficient use of time both for Pandora users and staff.

Thanks!

Labels (1)
63 Replies

BPLemings
Local Performer

It's on bandcamp too dummy. 

0 Kudos

Listener001
Not applicable
"Wow... where do I start? So I won't. But I will say that any tard with a computer and a gram of ketamine can now create music. This must be you. You're upset because you think you somehow get away with fooling people with your AI slop. NO ONE wants this **ahem**, and I hope you starve trying to sling it like a bad party drug. I am not going to use the words they use about AI slop in the 'real' music industry because I would get banned. You need to get a real job and stop trying to make money off of fake **ahem**! No participation trophy for you either! Thank you too!"
 
 
0 Kudos

Listener001
Not applicable

Wow, the name fits....leming...just add another "m."

0 Kudos

Ara_piano
Local Performer

@Listener001 @Seriously? Again? Can you prove what you're saying? Where are the "dozens" of albums I supposedly have released (I don't have any albums finished) and the "thousands" or "hundreds" of songs I've supposedly released, which barely reach a hundred in four years of work? Do you want to talk to one of the many pianists I collaborate with so they can explain the composition and recording processes to you? Do you want me to send you my MIDI files, my original piano audio tracks before mastering (I have them all)? Do you want me to explain how I record with my Yamaga DGX 660 and then master with Ableton Live and the Noire and Noire Felt plugins? Do you want to talk to some of the other composers who have helped me install and learn to use the DAW because I used to pay to have my songs mastered, and now I do it myself? Have you even bothered to watch my videos on Instagram of me playing each of the pieces I release? Since everything you say is falsehoods against me and my music, which costs me a lot of time, money, and effort, I have already said many times that I will take action against whomever I have to in order to clear my name and stop the damage being done to me and my work as an independent artist if you do not delete this comment immediately.

0 Kudos