Iphone 12 pro max, Ipad pro, Windows 10 Home, Echo 1st gen, Echo Plus 2nd gen and Echo Dot 2nd gen. My Pandora stations include everyday listening and holiday listening. From Nov-Jan I select all my holiday stations and shuffle them daily. Then mid-Jan-Oct I switch back and select my other stations and deselect my holiday stations. I enjoy a variety of genres and shuffling my stations had been my preferred way of listening to music. However, this year, 2021 when I edited my shuffle list it shuffles every station I've ever listened to including holiday music. I've edited the list many times and by logging into my account on a variety of devices, nothing I've done has fixed this problem. It doesn't work by voice command or by manually selecting shuffle stations when tapping the toggle. Because of this, I'm no longer listening to pandora often - I'd love to find a solution.
Moderator Edit: Changing title for clarity
I've got the same issue. Pandora seems to be shuffling in deselected stations both via web interface (Chrome - w10) and via app interface (Android 11). I've tried uninstalling the app and reinstalling it, changing my station selections, etc.
I am having the same issue since June 2021. Pandora Support keeps telling me that their engineers are aware of the issue and they are working on it. They also tell me that Pandora gets updated frequently, so keep updating the app to see if the fix has been delivered. However, the last update in Google Play Store from September 2021 did not fix the shuffle issue. Shuffle still plays all of my stations on both my Android and laptops. Very frustrating!
I finally got mine to shuffle all the stations on my computer! These were the directions online:
Click the carat icon next to Shuffle and choose either Shuffle All or Custom. To customize your Shuffle: You can customize the station included in your shuffle selection by: Hovering over the Shuffle On icon which will appear on the Now Playing screen which will reveal a pencil icon.
I am still suffering the issue reported by @peachytina @t0astm0nkey @Korndog101 . The fix reported by @mtmom406 does not fix our issue. It appears that @mtmom406 was trying to shuffle all of her stations. The issue that remains unresolved is only shuffling stations that we select to be shuffled via Custom shuffle. The 4 of us with this issue cannot stop Pandora shuffle mode from excluding the unselected stations from being shuffled in Custom shuffle mode. For us, there is no difference between selecting Shuffle All vs. Custom. 😞