Let's try a couple of troubleshooting steps for your Android, @Tehwanderer.
You mentioned clearing the Bluetooth cache, but let's also clear the Pandora app data and cache. You can do that with the following steps:
Note: You may need to re-download some of their offline content after this. Pandora Plus users, should receive that offline content again automatically. If you have any trouble with your offline stations after this, please let us know.
Open your device Settings
Tap Apps
Scroll down to find Pandora
Select Storage
On the storage details page tap Clear Data.
You will be asked to log into your account after completing these steps. Let me know if you need help signing back in.
Use your mobile device only when conditions allow and as permitted by applicable law.
... View more