Hi @webphut74 , welcome to the Pandora Community!  Thanks for posting and sorry for the confusion. Thumbs are station specific, so giving a Thumb rating on one station will not affect any of your other station or playlist. So even if you removed a thumb up from a song on a station it will continue to exist on your My Thumbs Up Playlist. I think it is a great idea to have a way to remove a duplicated song. You may want to check the Idea section to see if someone has already proposed anything similar and upvote that idea with a 💙 or post a brand new idea for the rest of the community to see. In the meantime, to remove songs from a playlist on your mobile device: In Edit mode, tap ( - ) on iOS or ( X ) on Android next to the track. Press Done (iOS) or Save (Android) to confirm your changes. Alternatively, while viewing your playlist, you can remove a song by swiping left on it. Hope this helps. ... View more